Uploaded image for project: 'Core Server'
  1. Core Server
  2. SERVER-33593

Heavy escaping required in shell for LDAP DNs with special characters

    • Type: Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Duplicate
    • Priority: Icon: Minor - P4 Minor - P4
    • None
    • Affects Version/s: 3.4.13, 3.6.3
    • Component/s: Shell
    • None
    • ALL
    • Hide

      mongod.conf excerpt:

      security:
        authorization: enabled
        ldap:
          servers: "ad.acme.qa"
          bind:
            queryUser: "mdb@acme.qa"
            queryPassword: 'Pa$$w0rd'
          transportSecurity: none
      setParameter:
        authenticationMechanisms: "PLAIN,GSSAPI,SCRAM-SHA-1"
      

      LDAP object's definition:

      $ ldapsearch -LLL -H ldaps://ad.acme.qa:636 -D "mdb@acme.qa" -w 'Pa$$w0rd' -x -b 'DC=acme,DC=qa' '(samAccountName=john.doe)' dn
      dn: CN=Doe\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\, left and right par
       ens),DC=ACME,DC=QA
      

      1. Unsuccessful authentication
      1.1. MongoDB user creation:

      MongoDB Enterprise > db.getSiblingDB('$external').createUser({user: 'CN=Doe\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA', roles: [ { role: 'root', db: 'admin' } ] });
      Successfully added user: {
      	"user" : "CN=Doe\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA",
      	"roles" : [
      		{
      			"role" : "root",
      			"db" : "admin"
      		}
      	]
      }
      

      1.2. Authentication attempt in MongoDB Shell:

      MongoDB Enterprise > db.getSiblingDB('$external').auth({user: "CN=Doe\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA", pwd: 'Pa$$w0rd', mechanism: 'PLAIN'});
      Error: Authentication failed.
      0
      

      1.3. MongoDB log entries:

      2018-03-01T03:13:16.267-0800 D ACCESS   [conn3] Binding to LDAP server "default" with bind parameters: {BindDN: CN=Doe, authenticationType: simple}
      2018-03-01T03:13:16.270-0800 E ACCESS   [conn3] Failed to bind to LDAP server at default: Invalid credentials. Bind parameters were: {BindDN: CN=Doe, authenticationType: simple}
      2018-03-01T03:13:16.270-0800 I ACCESS   [conn3] PLAIN authentication failed for CN=Doe\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA on $external from client 127.0.0.1:39416 ; OperationFailed: LDAP bind failed with error: Invalid credentials
      

      2. Successful authentication
      2.1. MongoDB user creation:

      MongoDB Enterprise > db.getSiblingDB('$external').createUser({user: 'CN=Doe\\\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA', roles: [ { role: 'root', db: 'admin' } ] });
      Successfully added user: {
      	"user" : "CN=Doe\\\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA",
      	"roles" : [
      		{
      			"role" : "root",
      			"db" : "admin"
      		}
      	]
      }
      

      2.2. Authentication attempt in MongoDB Shell:

      MongoDB Enterprise > db.getSiblingDB('$external').auth({user: "CN=Doe\\\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA", pwd: 'Pa$$w0rd', mechanism: 'PLAIN'});
      1
      

      2.3. MongoDB log entries:

      2018-03-01T03:22:05.621-0800 D ACCESS   [conn4] Binding to LDAP server "default" with bind parameters: {BindDN: CN=Doe\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA, authenticationType: simple}
      2018-03-01T03:22:05.631-0800 I ACCESS   [conn4] Successfully authenticated as principal CN=Doe\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA on $external
      
      Show
      mongod.conf excerpt: security: authorization: enabled ldap: servers: "ad.acme.qa" bind: queryUser: "mdb@acme.qa" queryPassword: 'Pa$$w0rd' transportSecurity: none setParameter: authenticationMechanisms: "PLAIN,GSSAPI,SCRAM-SHA-1" LDAP object's definition: $ ldapsearch -LLL -H ldaps://ad.acme.qa:636 -D "mdb@acme.qa" -w 'Pa$$w0rd' -x -b 'DC=acme,DC=qa' '(samAccountName=john.doe)' dn dn: CN=Doe\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\, left and right par ens),DC=ACME,DC=QA 1. Unsuccessful authentication 1.1. MongoDB user creation: MongoDB Enterprise > db.getSiblingDB('$external').createUser({user: 'CN=Doe\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA', roles: [ { role: 'root', db: 'admin' } ] }); Successfully added user: { "user" : "CN=Doe\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA", "roles" : [ { "role" : "root", "db" : "admin" } ] } 1.2. Authentication attempt in MongoDB Shell: MongoDB Enterprise > db.getSiblingDB('$external').auth({user: "CN=Doe\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA", pwd: 'Pa$$w0rd', mechanism: 'PLAIN'}); Error: Authentication failed. 0 1.3. MongoDB log entries: 2018-03-01T03:13:16.267-0800 D ACCESS [conn3] Binding to LDAP server "default" with bind parameters: {BindDN: CN=Doe, authenticationType: simple} 2018-03-01T03:13:16.270-0800 E ACCESS [conn3] Failed to bind to LDAP server at default: Invalid credentials. Bind parameters were: {BindDN: CN=Doe, authenticationType: simple} 2018-03-01T03:13:16.270-0800 I ACCESS [conn3] PLAIN authentication failed for CN=Doe\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA on $external from client 127.0.0.1:39416 ; OperationFailed: LDAP bind failed with error: Invalid credentials 2. Successful authentication 2.1. MongoDB user creation: MongoDB Enterprise > db.getSiblingDB('$external').createUser({user: 'CN=Doe\\\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA', roles: [ { role: 'root', db: 'admin' } ] }); Successfully added user: { "user" : "CN=Doe\\\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA", "roles" : [ { "role" : "root", "db" : "admin" } ] } 2.2. Authentication attempt in MongoDB Shell: MongoDB Enterprise > db.getSiblingDB('$external').auth({user: "CN=Doe\\\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA", pwd: 'Pa$$w0rd', mechanism: 'PLAIN'}); 1 2.3. MongoDB log entries: 2018-03-01T03:22:05.621-0800 D ACCESS [conn4] Binding to LDAP server "default" with bind parameters: {BindDN: CN=Doe\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA, authenticationType: simple} 2018-03-01T03:22:05.631-0800 I ACCESS [conn4] Successfully authenticated as principal CN=Doe\\, John (the second one),OU=FooBar (with commas\\, left and right parens),DC=ACME,DC=QA on $external

      Users currently need to use 4 backslashes instead of expected 2 to escape LDAP DNs with special characters in order to authenticate.

            Assignee:
            backlog-server-platform DO NOT USE - Backlog - Platform Team
            Reporter:
            andrey.brindeyev@mongodb.com Andrey Brindeyev
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            5 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: